I just wanted to say two things, if you're just arriving now and missed it:
- I responded to Isaac's charge, quoted at the end of the piece, that I was taking Thomas Garvey in good faith here.
- One odd omission from the Guardian piece is RVCBard's stance on the issue, since after all it was her comments that Garvey latched onto and started the whole thing, and without her the issue would probably have died away much quicker and been less interesting. Anyways, this is her biggest response to the debate, and this is her last one. They're crucial to understanding what happened.